GARMIN APPROACH S12 BLACK vs Garmin vivoactive 5: which one suits you?

The two differ in 4 of the specs we have recorded, and the GARMIN APPROACH S12 BLACK is cheaper by SAR 120 (prices checked 17 Nov 2026).

Bottom line: GARMIN APPROACH S12 BLACK — Larger display size: 1.3 in vs 1.2 in. Garmin vivoactive 5 — Charge less often through the week (11 days vs 1.3 days). Amazon.sa prices checked 17 November 2026.

Which one should you choose?

  • Paying less: cheaper by SAR 120
  • Larger display size: 1.3 in vs 1.2 in · slight difference
  • Charge less often through the week (11 days vs 1.3 days)
  • Lower weight: 26 g vs 34 g

The deciding difference here: battery life and weight and price.

Compares recorded specs; a missing spec does not mean the feature is absent.

Key differences

  • Display type

    DigitalAMOLED
  • Display size

    ✓ 1.3 in1.2 in
  • Battery life

    1.3 days✓ 11 days

Specifications side by side

12 of 12 specs

Scroll the table sideways to see the rest.

Spec
GarminSAR 1,119
GARMIN APPROACH S12 BLACK specs
GarminSAR 1,239
Garmin vivoactive 5 specs
Reference priceSAR 1,119SAR 1,239
Battery life1.3 days✓ 11 days
Phone compatibilitySmartwatch—
Built-in GPSYesYes

Facts come from each Amazon.sa listing. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Buying through our links costs you nothing extra.

Before you buy

Prices, availability, shipping and returns can change. Check the final details on Amazon.sa before you buy.

Similar comparisons

Direct comparison questions

What is the difference in battery life between the GARMIN APPROACH S12 BLACK and the Garmin vivoactive 5?

Battery life is higher on the Garmin vivoactive 5: 11 days vs 1.3 days on the GARMIN APPROACH S12 BLACK. If this spec is your priority, the difference favours it.

What is the difference in built-in GPS between the GARMIN APPROACH S12 BLACK and the Garmin vivoactive 5?

No difference here: built-in GPS is Yes on both.

What is the difference in display type between the GARMIN APPROACH S12 BLACK and the Garmin vivoactive 5?

GARMIN APPROACH S12 BLACK: Digital; Garmin vivoactive 5: AMOLED. This is a spec difference, not a verdict that one is better overall.

What is the difference in display size between the GARMIN APPROACH S12 BLACK and the Garmin vivoactive 5?

Display size is higher on the GARMIN APPROACH S12 BLACK: 1.3 in vs 1.2 in on the Garmin vivoactive 5. If this spec is your priority, the difference favours it.